Ok now let’s get into some fun stuff: Opening up a search console:
@Impassioned has volunteered her site https://www.parkcity4u.com and shared that she feels she used to rank a lot better but now doesn’t rank as well.
She recently upgraded to Renaissance and has been putting in the work, hoping to improve her SEO.
Let’s dig in!
First, test the theory. Have rankings really dropped? (we check search console)
What I like to do is find the highest traffic “by impressions” keyword which is also typically one of the most competitive. In her case it’s “Park City Real Estate”
Now search console only goes back so far, but from what I can tell in the past 12 months the keyword has bounced around a bit but you’re actually within a range:
Today you’re at 12.1 (that’s good, it means you’re in striking distance for a hugely competitive keyword)
And 12 months ago? You were 11.7
So really you have not changed by any appreciable margin in the last 12 months. Some ups and downs but nothing that looks like a drop off the face of the earth.
So how do we crack the top 10?
Honestly, your domain https://www.parkcity4u.com you’ve done a pretty great job on developing your homepage content (the page that is currently ranking)
There are a few small things you could do to further focus on “real estate” terms as opposed to mixing it in with condos, homes for sale etc, but in this example (because it’s a homepage) I would actually prefer you keep it as it is, since the purpose of a homepage is to act as an index for the whole site (which is why I often don’t optimize homepages as much as internal pages).
So the #1: Recommendation since your homepage content is solid (and you’re clearly in the mix) is you need to build a few backlinks. (Not a 100, just a few)
These links should be targetted and relevant (that means they could be from real estate authority sites, or from local park city sites, or both)
The anchor text you use should be specific to your keywords (if you can get it) for example “Park City Real Estate” “Park City Utah Real Estate” etc.
But don’t look for easy links. Basic trades, guest posts etc won’t cut it. We need true authority here. Try to think of some ways you can leverage your relationships (groups you belong to, local not for profits you donate to, press relationships you have) that sort of thing.
I wrote a post on link building and authority (which I should probably update for 2023 as things have changed a bit) but you should find it a helpful primer.
This is not to say the rest of your site is perfect when it comes to content though - you actually have several areas that you could improve the pages significantly while employing the Pillar strategy, and could likely boost your Park City rankings.
Let’s take this page Park City MLS Homes for Sale in Park City Utah
This page is no good (sorry) and it’s linked to right from your home page.
Why is it no good?
Because this is the only content on the page that is not duplicate
So you have this massive amount of listings on the main page (too many to be honest) and almost no high-quality/unique content.
The title is super spammy too (Park City MLS Homes For Sale In Park City Utah) … would you click on that in Google? Remember, click-through rate matters!
How could this example page be improved?
#1: Focus. What is the true intent of this page? I “think” it is meant to be “all current homes for sale in Park City” is that right? So why not make it all about that instead of including all these other areas like Kamas etc.
What about this for a title: ALL Homes For Sale In Park City New Every 15 Mins
Wouldn’t that get more clicks?
Now on the “on page” content. I think you know about thin content (unuseful) content already. So what I’ll say is that this page needs it’s ratio of listings to content fixed.
Set the users expectation: Why did you create this page, and why is it truly more valuable than any other page they might find out there.
What’s going on with homes in Park City - that is what they are searching for, but would they logically have questions? Pique their interest (it can be a jump link after the listings)
Can you get some easy win FAQ’s in there
What is the buying process like in Park City for out of state buyers?
What are the property taxes in Park City?
How much maintenance does a winter home require if I’m not always there?
See where I’m going with this?
Now I know I said that technical SEO comes after content and links (but we’ve covered quite a lot on that already) so definitely read up on the elements above (review all your support pages and make sure they are super high quality, linking back to their pillars) write your blog posts as instructed above etc.
But in your case, since you’re “so close” to the top for some really great keywords, you’re a candidate for doing some more technical SEO. I created a thread with some recommendations for programmatic SEO right here if you’re interested.
A couple of other things to check in on are ADA accessibility and Google page speed.
On accessibility (at least on your homepage) you have achieved god mode! (congrats!) this is the best I’ve seen (you’re literally perfect)
For page speed - it’s Renaissance, so it’s going to be fast (especially on desktop)
But on mobile there is some room for improvement: But this is hyper-technical stuff (and you do have a lot going on for your homepage). 79 is “not bad”, but could be fine-tuned (some image optimization, consolidation of third-party scripts, (maybe even cleaning up, removing some) deferring or lazy loading some of those further down elements etc. There is a whole thread on WPO here as well for that.